Report a claim anytime online or by phone.
For fast, efficient claims service, please call, fax, or email us during normal working hours. For after-hours service, please locate your insurance company and claims number below. Most of our companies offer 24-hour claims service.
Company | Claim Numbers |
Erie Insurance Group | (800) 367-3743 |
Foremost | (800) 527-3907 |
Grinnell Mutual | (877) 467-2252 |
Ohio Fair Plan | (800) 282-1772 |
Pennsylvania Fair Plan | (800) 462-4972 |
Pennsylvania Lumbermens Insurance Co. | (800) 752-1895 |
Progressive | (800) 776-4737 |
Sandy & Beaver | (800) 421-4693 |
Travelers Insurance Co. | (800) 252-4633 |
Our agents are ready to help! If you have any questions, please call or email your appropriate office location below. Pennsylvania policyholders should contact our office in Conneaut.
- Ashtabula County Phone: (440) 593-3562 or 866-208-1222 or email Conneaut here.
- Lake County Phone (440) 354-4933 or 866-556-7575 or email Mentor here.